Best Furnace parts supplier in Cleveland for SameDay Service

Menyhart Plumbing & Heating Supply Co is a plumbing and heating supply store at 6304 Lorain Ave in Cleveland's Detroit-Shoreway neighborhood, serving contractors and DIY homeowners rather than operating as a service contractor. Its shelves carry plumbing equipment and parts, heating equipment and parts, water heaters, bathtubs, and fixtures including hard-to-find faucet stems and obscure legacy components. It also stocks HVAC parts such as capacitors for do-it-yourself air conditioner repairs. Reviews focus on the counter staff's parts knowledge: customers describe walking in with unidentified broken shower stems or old furnace components and getting exact matches pulled from inventory or catalogs on the spot. One customer who could not buy a capacitor from contractor-only suppliers got the part at Menyhart and avoided a full installed repair. Staff give installation tips, discourage overselling, and even accept texted photos to verify furnace parts before a drive. Saturday hours make it reachable for weekend projects. This is a fit for homeowners of older Cleveland houses hunting for discontinued or hard-to-identify plumbing and heating parts, and for DIYers who want counter-level guidance before attempting a repair. Trade professionals use it as a parts source alongside big-box stores. For anyone who has brought a mystery part to multiple stores without success, the review record of instant identification and honest pricing makes it worth the trip — just expect a supply counter, not a service van.